True Crime Chat With Mommy Ramblings

Facts Not Fluff

Follow Us

Mommy

REVERSED: Letecia Stauch’s Conviction Overturned—What the 54-Page Ruling Means for Gannon’s Case

by Leave a Comment

In a decision that has sent shockwaves through the LawTube community and the 4th Judicial District, the Colorado Court of Appeals has officially reversed the conviction of Letecia Stauch.

Yesterday, April 2, 2026, a three-judge panel issued a 54-page ruling (Case No. 23CA1067-PD) vacating her 2023 life sentence and remanding the case for a brand-new trial. For those of us who have followed Gannon’s story from the very beginning, this news is as frustrating as it is significant.

The Technicality: Juror M.B. and “Structural Error”

The reversal isn’t about new evidence or a change in the facts of what happened to Gannon. Instead, it rests on a legal technicality known as Structural Error.

According to the opinion authored by Judge Neeti Pawar, the trial court made a critical mistake during jury selection. One of the jurors who deliberated, identified as Juror M.B., had a son-in-law who worked as a Deputy District Attorney in the very office prosecuting the case (the El Paso County DA’s Office).

Under Colorado law, a juror with such a close tie to the prosecutor’s office should have been dismissed automatically for implied bias. Because the defense’s challenge to remove this juror was denied and Juror M.B. went on to deliberate, the Court of Appeals ruled that the “appearance of fairness” was compromised. In the eyes of the law, this is a “structural error” that requires an automatic reversal of the verdict—regardless of the overwhelming evidence presented at trial.

Where Do We Go From Here?

The case is now being sent back to the El Paso County District Court. While the 4th Judicial District Attorney’s Office has expressed deep disappointment, they have signaled they are “undeterred” in their search for justice and are prepared to present the case to a new jury if a petition to the Colorado Supreme Court doesn’t change the outcome.

Why the 2020 Arrest Affidavit Matters Now

As we prepare for a potential second trial, we have to go back to the source. The Original Arrest Affidavit from 2020 is the roadmap for the prosecution’s case. It contains the 911 calls, the initial “abductor” stories, and the forensic timeline that led investigators to that suitcase in Florida.

If this case is retried, the prosecution will have to build that wall of evidence all over again.

JOIN THE LIVE REFRESHER TONIGHT

I am going live tonight on the Mommy Ramblings YouTube channel to do a page-by-page breakdown of that 2020 Affidavit. We need to refresh our memory on the facts so we can see how they hold up against this new legal reality.

Kouri Richins Trial: The Defense Rests—What Comes Next?

by

UPDATE (March 12, 2026): The Defense has officially rested its case. We are now entering the final, decisive phase of the trial: Closing Arguments. > JOIN THE LIVE RECAP TONIGHT: I am going live tonight to break down the key takeaways from the Defense’s case and answer your questions as we prepare for the verdict.

The live courtroom drama surrounding the death of Utah dad and husband,Eric Richins, has gripped the nation, and today, we reached a major turning point. After weeks of intense testimony, the State has rested its case-in-chief in the murder trial of Eric’s wife, Kouri Richins.

“WATCH LIVE: We are streaming the defense’s case-in-chief right now. Click HERE to join the live coverage on YouTube.”

For those just following this true crime case, Kouri Richins—a Utah mother and self-published children’s author—stands accused of the 2022 fentaNYL poisoning death of her husband, Eric Richins. Prosecutors have spent the last twelve days painting a picture of financial desperation, alleged infidelity, and a calculated effort to stage a tragedy.

From the “Orange Notebook” entries to the controversial “Walk The Dog” letter, the evidence presented has been nothing short of sensational. The State has meticulously built a narrative of motive, centering on massive debt and life insurance policies.

Today, the trajectory of this trial changes. The burden of proof remains with the State, but the Defense now has their opportunity to present its reality. We expect to see them challenge the prosecution’s timeline, dismantle the testimony of key witnesses, and provide an alternative theory regarding Eric Richins’ tragic end.

Are these notes the writings of a guilty woman, or the ramblings of someone under extreme duress? Is there evidence that the prosecution has missed, or is the defense chasing shadows?

Follow the Trial Live-Understanding this trial requires more than just reading the headlines. It requires looking at the documents, watching the cross-examinations as they happen, and analyzing the testimony in real-time.

I am providing live, gavel-to-gavel coverage of the defense’s case-in-chief. You don’t have to miss a second of the testimony that will decide the outcome of this case.

I encourage you to join our community in the chat. We are committed to document-based, factual reporting and unbiased analysis. Whether you are a legal expert or an armchair detective, your voice is a part of the conversation.

The trial continues. Let’s see what the defense has in store.

Casey Anthony – Check Out Our True Crime Series

by

Who can forget the shock and horror at the jury’s verdict in the Casey Anthony Case? I sure can’t. I also have a vivid memory of one of her attorneys, who gained his “fame” in that case and became one of most sought after defense attorneys in the world, Jose Baez. In fact, he is representing the daughter of Stampin’ Up founder Shanna Gardner. Shanna is going to trial late this summer for the brutal murder of her ex-husband, Jared Bridegan.

We are revisiting the Casey Anthony Case and you can find our multi-part series on our YouTube Playlist. We are broadcasting live every evening, so join us to talk about the true crime cases you follow. You will find your tribe.

Why I Believe Wendi Adelson Knew About The Hit on Her Ex-Husband

by

I was sent the file of this police interview with Wendi Adelson’ by the Tallahassee PD after requesting it via FOIA. Our two part video series below contains some of my analysis of the things Wendi said that implicate her in the murder of her ex-husband Dan Markel. What kinds of things do you think Wendi Adelson has said and done, including in this interview, that cause the prosecutor to label her an unindicted co-conspirator in the murder of her ex-husband Dan Markel.

Mackenzie Shirilla’s Shocking Jail Calls – We Have Them All

by

Mackenzie Shirilla, a Strongsville, Ohio teenager, was convicted of intentionally crashing her car at nearly 100 mph, killing her boyfriend, Dominic Russo, and a friend. Her family maintains that the crash was an accident caused by an undiagnosed medical condition, but her appeals have been denied.

In the early morning of July 31, 2022, 17-year-old Mackenzie Shirilla drove her Toyota Camry into a large brick commercial building. 20-year-old boyfriend, Dominic Russo, and 19-year-old friend, Davion Flanagan were killed on impact. Data from the car’s event recorder showed that Shirilla floored the accelerator in the moments before the impact and never hit the brakes. Shirilla survived the crash but was seriously injured.

During a bench trial presided over by Cuyahoga County Judge Nancy Margaret Russo, the prosecution argued that Shirilla deliberately carried out a premeditated murder. Evidence showed Shirilla had been in a toxic relationship with Russo and had previously threatened to crash the car while arguing with him.The vehicle’s data showed that Shirilla accelerated to 100 mph before impact and did not brake, a fact the judge cited to indicate intent.There was security footage played in court that showed the car moving at normal speed, then suddenly accelerating right before the crash.

In August 2023, the judge convicted Shirilla on all 12 counts, including four counts of murder. “She had a mission, and she executed it with precision,” the judge stated. Mackenzie Shirilla and her family have consistently maintained that the crash was a tragic accident. Shirilla’s family claims she experienced a sudden medical event, possibly related to her Postural Orthostatic Tachycardia Syndrome (POTS), that caused her to lose consciousness. Mackenzie Shirilla was sentenced to two concurrent 15-year-to-life sentences for the murders, with eligibility for parole after 15 years.

Mackenzie Shirilla is serving her sentence in a women’s prison in Ohio. New jail calls have been released that are very shocking and I decided to get all the discovery, police cams and jail calls and do a Mommy Ramblings True Crime Deep Dive into this case.

Our YouTube Channel has many videos on the case of Makenzie Shirilla. Her jail calls while awaiting trial and immediately after she was found guilty and then sentenced were sent to me after a FOIA request I made. I have every phone call released in a series of videos. The first two volumes can be found below and the others will be posted here but can be found right now on our Youtube Channel. Let me know your thoughts in the comments.